Two men to remember

| 6 Comments

Hello, everyone --

This is my first post after a long absence. I've been back in the country for about three weeks after being in the Middle East for almost all of 2003, on a goodwill tour with the U.S. Marine Corps. It's good to be back to see my wife, children (one more arrived while I was away), home, etc., and it's good to be able to write things here once again.

I've thought of many things to comment upon, but I wanted to begin with one topic that's been troubling me for some time. A couple of weeks ago, PFC Jessica Lynch went home after months of physical therapy. For those of you who haven't watched the news this year, PFC Lynch is the U.S. soldier injured in an attack on her convoy in Nasiriyah, Iraq, on March 23. Initially, reports based on intercepted Iraqi radio transmissions said that she fought her attackers, but later evidence revealed that she was almost certainly unable to fight because of the massive injuries she suffered in her vehicle's collision.

So you probably know who Jessica Lynch is; you probably know that she has received a Bronze Star medal, as well as magazine covers, offers of exclusive, in-depth interviews, and all the attendant glories of saturation-level media coverage. She has a boyfriend who is a sergeant (in violation of Army fraternization rules). Her recovery looks like it will be complete.

I don't wish PFC Lynch ill -- quite the opposite. I was in Nasiriyah when special forces teams stormed the hospital where she was being kept, and as we knew the raid was imminent, I prayed for her safety. Our task force carried out an attack to divert attention away from the Lynch rescue. My civil affairs team, attached to 2nd Battalion, 8th Marine infantry regiment, contributed to the intelligence that identified her location. (Several civilians came forward to tell us where she was being kept, and Marines on my team found evidence of her previous location which indicated that she was still alive. I had nothing to do with these efforts, as I happened to be carrying out other duties when these things happened.)

What bothers me isn't that she's famous. What does bother me is that two Marines laid down their lives trying to save her and her comrades, and nobody knows who they are. I don't even know their names, though I've spent a considerable amount of time trying to figure it out. They are two of the nine Marines who died on that sunny, mild day, but none of the news accounts or Pentagon reports that I've seen mention how each one died. Perhaps they think it's not important; I happen to think it is. The only reason I heard about them at all is because of two news stories that mentioned in passing that two Marines died while trying to get to Lynch's convoy, where several soldiers were dead or seriously wounded.

They were young men racing to the assistance of their countrymen, plunging themselves into imminent danger along with dozens of others. Unfortunately for them and their families, they were unlucky enough to be in the path of a bullet or the blast radius of a mortar shell. "Greater love has no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends," Jesus said. These men gave their lives for complete strangers. And nobody knows their names.

It's possible that those news reports were wrong, though I did talk to Marines with that battalion who confirmed the details. Even if they are wrong, there were nine Marines and several soldiers who perished the same day. They weren't "news," though -- it's not counterintuitive for a 19-year-old guy from Brooklyn to die in battle. A pretty, wholesome-looking blond girl from a rural town makes for a much better profile in People magazine, and it has the novelty factor going for it. Also, news editors -- almost all of whom are parishioners at the Church of Diversity Uber Alles -- adore story lines involving women doing activities that men used to monopolize. From the moment the Iraqis dragged Lynch's unconscious body away from her wrecked Humvee, she was destined to be a media star.

This speaks volumes about our culture: the mass media not only have a warped sense of proportion and values, so do large numbers of media consumers as well; the media know their market, and they know lots of people are interested in stories like Jessica Lynch.

A part of my motivation is because on a few occasions during the battle for that city, my team could have met the same fate. Mainly, though, I believe at least some of the glory given to Lynch rightfully belongs to others, too. So if you know the names of the two Marines who died while rescuing that convoy, let me know. I'd like to pray for their souls by their names, and for their families.

6 Comments

Fully agreed, Eric! While Jessica Lynch is certainly deserving of honor for service to her country, the media blew it all out of proportion for the sake of a good story and to put a politically correct face (young, female soldier in combat) on the conflict. That's the nature of the media beast in this age.

All military personnel, not only those involved in the rescue of PFC Lynch, but in the Iraqi conflict in general are just as deserving of the heaps of gratitude that have been sent in her direction.

Eric,
Welcome home. I agree with you wholeheartedly. We buried a young pfc out of my parish in Brooklyn last Friday. He died when a grenade was thrown at him while he was guarding a hospital. Very little mention was made of the funeral in the NYC papers. May God receive all of those who gave their lives in Iraq. I pray for them and those still serving in that terrible heat. When the electricity went out here in New YOrk last night everyone was complaining about the lack of air conditioning. My mother's response was "think of those poor servicemen in Iraq in that terrible heat." Thank you for your service.

Brave men lived before Homer

Welcome Home!

Keep in mind that Military Glory has always been extremely fickle.
_

Maybe, but the glory of serving your fellow man unto death is eternal.

Great to see you back at Catholic Light. (And it'll be great to see you back at work next week.) Excellent post as well. If you ever find out the soldiers' names, please do post it.

Hello all,
My name is Tory and I am doing research on those of the convoy that contained Jessica Lynch. I think that all the publicity she is getting is uncalled for and undeserved. I am not saying she didn't go through a lot but I am upset that those who actually laid down their lives for others and those who were also injured have not received credit. Her $1 million book deal is ludicrous and I am hoping to do something about it. I am wanting to either write a paper or book dedicated to the families who lost someone in the war and about the ones in her convoy who I have never heard any of their names. I am hoping that if this book happens more people will look more closely into why they think JL is such a "hero". I am also hoping to write another book about the people who no one ever mentioned and that was the contract workers who had the choice of going over there or not and did serve their country. Any information you could supply me so that I could get in contact with the families of those in the convoy so that I can get their permission and get the back stories on the ones who have received no credit I would greatly appreciate it. If you know anyone who could also help please give them my email addy.
Thank you so much,
Tory Gore
unsungheros2003@yahoo.com

What? Who?

On life and living in communion with the Catholic Church.

Richard Chonak

John Schultz


You write, we post
unless you state otherwise.

Archives

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Eric Johnson published on August 15, 2003 1:49 AM.

Ruh-roh! was the previous entry in this blog.

Good news from NYC (for some) is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.