Phil Lawler of Catholic World News grouses about the parish closings in his e-mail today:
Closing parishes might solve the superficial problem, by saving money. But it doesn’t solve the deeper problem. If there’s a long-term plan in place for revitalizing the archdiocese– getting ordinary Catholics back to church– I haven’t heard about it.
I don’t want to lump Phil in with some of my fellow parishioners, but they make the same complaint too, and in their case I call it whining, because they speak of long-term efforts to preach the gospel and re-convert the lapsed faithful as a substitute for consolidating parishes.
That’s a losing proposal from the start: instead of correcting real current problems with overextended priests and underfunded, underattended parishes, it tells everybody to keep paying and praying, and tells Father to keep saying four Masses on Sunday, and makes the future of the Church dependent on the return of people who have left the Church!
Look, miracles are great, and a substantial re-conversion of lapsed Catholics would be one, but to base the Church’s pastoral strategy on them would be somewhere between irresponsibility and presumption.