Is Gerry Matatics a Sedevacantist?

Admittedly, I find myself respectfully disagreeing with a rather formidable lineup. After all, it is not everyday that Karl Keating, Bob Sungenis, Tom Woods, John Pacheco, Jimmy Akin, and the Dimond Brothers find themselves in agreement on something. Yet like everything else when it comes to Gerry, I don’t feel the answer is as clear as it first appears. This is why, over at Lidless-Eye Inquisition, I’ve been offering my own perspective on the whole Matatics affair. One thing I will agree with, however, is that Keating has now been vindicated.